The US is set to introduce a 30-day ceasefire proposal negotiated with Ukraine to Russia in the coming days.

Trump administration officials are seeing it as a major breakthrough towards the foreign policy goals of a president who campaigned to end the war.

So does it make a ceasefire plausible? And if so, can it end the war after Russia's full-scale invasion three years ago in a just and sustainable way, and on terms that keep the region and the world safe?

Statement: "Ukraine expressed readiness to accept the U.S. proposal to enact an immediate, interim 30-day ceasefire, which can be extended by mutual agreement of the parties, and which is subject to acceptance and concurrent implementation by the Russian Federation. The United States will communicate to Russia that Russian reciprocity is the key to achieving peace."

Analysis: The key word here is "immediate," which doesn't leave any doubt: Trump wants the guns to fall silent now. His sense of urgency, however, has often led to concerns in Europe.

Many fear that rushing the desired outcome without first working out the terms takes the military pressure off Moscow as the invading power and could lead to a truce being exploited.

They argue it empowers the occupying force.

The fear is of ultimately leading Ukraine into an effective surrender. The theory is that Russia - the bigger, more populous and militarily more self-sufficient power - could use a truce without first establishing concessions to consolidate its forces, string out a negotiation process and wait to see what happens politically for Trump during his term while it holds on to everything it seized; and even then try to take more ground, building on its current occupation and potentially using a fracture in the Western alliance to threaten more of Europe.

The process of negotiating terms before a ceasefire in conflicts can be important to ensure the sides convert current military threats into meaningful strategic gains.

Zelensky has previously tried to persuade the Americans that Russian President Vladimir Putin cannot be trusted, evidenced by the fact he broke the European-backed Minsk agreements after seizing Ukrainian territory in 2014.

Trump dismisses these concerns, saying there will be security for Ukraine, but without saying how this will be assured. He has said Putin will be deterred and is in a difficult position with "no choice" but to make a deal for reasons that "only I know".

Rubio said on Tuesday the US delegation had substantive discussions with the Ukrainians on a permanent end to the war, including "what type of guarantees they're going to have for their long-term security and prosperity", but again didn't elaborate.

Media caption,

Watch: Rubio on how US wants Ukraine-Russia negotiations to work

Statement: "The United States will immediately lift the pause on intelligence sharing and resume security assistance to Ukraine."

Analysis: This is the big win for Zelensky in this agreement and sees US weapons supplies being delivered at a rate of around $2bn (£1.5bn)-worth a month, restored.

Critically, it also means Washington will once again share its intelligence data and satellite pictures with Kyiv, which helps it target Russian positions. The White House said it suspended this aid because it felt Zelensky wasn't "committed" to Trump's peace plan.

The Ukrainian leader had tried to voice his concerns based on some of the reasons above when he was ejected from the Oval Office. His reservations are likely being set aside while he welcomes the agreement in this form - a necessary price to pay to restore US security assistance.

Statement: "Both delegations agreed to name their negotiating teams and immediately begin negotiations toward an enduring peace that provides for Ukraine's long-term security. The United States committed to discussing these specific proposals with representatives from Russia. The Ukrainian delegation reiterated that European partners shall be involved in the peace process."

Analysis: This paragraph is confusing because it's unclear whether it refers to negotiations between Ukraine and the US on establishing any security guarantees for Ukraine, or if it refers to negotiations between Ukraine and Russia to permanently end the war once a ceasefire is under way.

If it is the former, it appears to suggest that Washington and Kyiv will hammer out any decisions on how to back up Ukraine's security and deter Russian breaches of a truce, and the US will then discuss these with Moscow.

But it is all a far cry from the kind of security guarantee Zelensky ultimately wanted, which was membership of Nato, which Trump has said won't happen - a major long-term concession to Moscow's demands.

The paragraph also contains a vague and lukewarm reference to the idea of European peacekeepers, which have been pitched by the UK and France, with the line attributed only to the Ukrainian delegation.

It's notable that the US appears not to be putting its name to this part after Moscow categorically rejected the idea.

Statement: "…both countries' presidents agreed to conclude as soon as possible a comprehensive agreement for developing Ukraine's critical mineral resources to expand Ukraine's economy and guarantee Ukraine's long-term prosperity and security."

Analysis: This was the agreement that never got signed after Zelensky was told to leave the White House last month.

It would give the US a future stake in some of Ukraine's state-owned mineral deposits, as well as oil and gas revenues.

Trump sees it as an effective security guarantee for Ukraine, arguing it would deter Russian re-invasion because American companies would be on the ground.

Opponents point out this is meaningless because US economic presence in Ukraine didn't deter Putin in 2014 or 2022.

Statement: "The Ukrainian delegation reiterated the Ukrainian people's strong gratitude to President Trump…"

Analysis: This is a key line that might help explain Zelenky's rehabilitation in the eyes of the White House.

Vance had castigated him in the Oval Office for not thanking Trump, even though the Ukrainian leader has thanked the US dozens of times for its military support.

Now Trump has an official Ukrainian thank you, on a piece of paper meant to make peace.

  • Published
    6 hours ago
  • Sturgeon remains the biggest name in Scottish politics

    A woman, photographed from the chest up, looking up and waving with her right hand. She has short brown hair, combed to the side, and is wearing a red top and matching red jacket. A large crowd of people are visible in the background in the image, which was taken in an auditorium.
  • Discuss the fascinating science suspended in solid water

  • Arctic air brings freeze to UK as weather warning issued
  • 相关内容推荐

    兴致勃勃的近义词安全感英文刘强东简历颠鸾倒凤不知天地为何物另类村姑zara西装王丽丹浮夸原唱李继周济南机场停车费trendiano爱相随周华健法师反制宏2的20次方是多少求全责备是什么意思假面的告白宁晋县天气预报昌都地图草婚益派调查网婺源地图永巷心如刀割吉他谱蔡裴琳从善如流的意思卡尺怎么用纯妆涟漪歌词摩尔庄园蘑菇洞好高骛远什么意思光年是多少故乡的云简谱马赫五号nevertheless消遣的意思教育改革的核心是痴心绝对伴奏锲而不舍造句保定市天气预报荷叶头暗涌歌词苏州轨道交通5号线宋祖英多大了速尔快递单号查询傅晶老公福州市格致中学国际收支申报toiletries放生回向如家连锁酒店官网盲目草范忠信优渥分外的意思关上最后的门漫画邓州市天气预报畅行仕途薛城舜耕中学朴诗妍曲阳天气预报美团卷我感动天感动地怎么感动不了你雷锋歌词猫耳宝贝鄙视表情沈泉庄村2pm朴宰范恶劣的近义词restaurant怎么读步步惊心台词中国国葬捆梆06年世界杯冠军洗纹身后的样子qq信息查询赵兰秀李丹宁后宫演员表恶人成长日记高丝护肤品牛津杯比利时甲级联赛lexon不如跳舞陈慧琳苏芒老公中国总统cmnet羸弱不堪苹果手机省电龙巡天下之血麒麟平安歌手演员张恒抛砖引玉造句迈克杰克逊怎么死的包青天之狄青噱头是什么意思ampm天目湖在哪里纯妆无法原谅简谱链家地产北京解脱张惠妹hen怎么读凌晨三点三分倪震个人资料火炬手小品金建模consulted银七星室内滑雪场凤栖梧柳永武侯祠大街踉跄扶沟地图火车票售票时间江南古镇苍白的近义词耒阳市地图2pm朴宰范beacon时槽歇后语千里送鹅毛刘德华的年龄再世篇攻略卡南犬putup女m现象七十二变梁佳玉全球票房排名张婉如半成品羽绒服qq体验中心爽口萝卜的做法邮政ems电话有情饮水饱谧的读音连云港招生考试信息网昆山一周天气预报爱情买卖djvip126邮箱登陆安徽亳州地图nba名人堂生化球qq邮箱漂流瓶星星知我心歌词disabled什么意思beefcake附庸风雅什么意思潘阳老公诺基亚3108开场音乐葛洪苦读渴望大结局contests梦远书城99年国庆大阅兵三股势力孙紫晴绿珠坠楼威尔斯科基犬爱和承诺zebra的音标decimeter又唱浏阳河简谱笔记本home键在哪橄榄油价格宾塔奇名侦探柯南十年后的陌生人斗犬宋琳琳春天来了简谱a5尺寸是多少牙牙学语的意思仙姿佚貌广州工商网草长莺飞是什么意思丧事歌曲孔明锁解法美味佳肴的意思considering谢德庆3mm倾城别恋新三民主义笑傲江湖曲谱ttsqz万宝路黑冰爆珠百度高级搜索serendipity坚硬的近义词韵达快递价格成都美术学院情人节多少号珍藏的近义词东风汽车价格薛必群婚誓简谱郑海霞个人资料韩国护肤品品牌辛德勒的名单主题曲

    站外内容推荐
    慈喀SEO百科 | 动画城资源 | 个人网站制作 | 网站SEO优化 | 网站seo优化 | 金凯德工作室 | 耗材资讯 | 优化网站关键词 | 优化网站关键词 | 百度seo公司 | 高端网站建设 | 网络营销推广 | 虚拟主机 | 北极图库 | 北极图库 | SEO学堂 | 企业网站建设 | 卡通粉丝俱乐部 | 耗材资讯 | 企业seo优化 | 驱动平台